top of page

We're so happy you're here!

Order personalized gifts by december 10

APPLE BUTTER DESIGNS

GIFTS, CUSTOM SIGNS, ENGRAVINGS & HOME DECOR

Home
About Us
Events
Wooden Signs
Shop
Hymnal Art
Gift Card
Christmas
More

Use tab to navigate through the menu items.

All
Christmas
Hymnal Art
Bookmarks
Greeting Cards
Car Charms
Wood Signs
Knit Beanies
Graduation
Jewelry
Custom Desk Nameplate
School Spirit
Card Keeper
Wedding
Ornaments/Gift Tags
Milkhouse Candle Co

$0

$65

Handwritten Ornament
Price$20.00
Hand-Painted

Joy
Price$15.00
Our Frosty
Price$6.00
Festive Napkin Holders
Price$4.00
Hand-Painted

Oh Christmas Tree
Regular Price$15.00Sale Price$10.00
Ornament

Crossword Puzzle Family Name Ornament
Price$13.50
Limited Quantity

Hand-Painted Ornament
Price$12.00
New Arrival

Farmhouse Chic Stocking Tags
Regular Price$12.25Sale Price$10.00
Personalize Me

Personalized Sports Jersey
Price$12.50
Recipe For Love
Price$30.00
Loved One's Own Handwriting Keepsake
PriceFrom $65.00
Milkhouse Candle Co Waxmelts
Price$9.75
ON SALE

Farmhouse Initial Engraved Ornament
Price$5.00
Sweet Friendship
Regular Price$16.00Sale Price$12.00
New Arrival

Knit Beanies
Price$16.00

Need a custom piece? Reach out to us here

Huge thank you to all that came out today!
My heart is so happy with y’all’s support of our small business! Don’t forget we will be open tomorrow, Small Business Saturday from 9-3 too! I’ll have warm & cozy spiced apple cider ready for you to sip, shop, and order your personalized gifts!

-Melissa

Huge thank you to all that came out today!
My heart is so happy with y’all’s support of our small business! Don’t forget we will be open tomorrow, Small Business Saturday from 9-3 too! I’ll have warm & cozy spiced apple cider ready for you to sip, shop, and order your personalized gifts!

-Melissa

These pretties will be available tomorrow at our in-person store.
Our area is calling for less than 3 inches of snow, som come see us! We’ll be open from 9-3 tomorrow!

Find us on Apple & Google Maps

#smallBusinessSaturday #shopSmallShopLocal #weCanShip #shopUsONLINE #AppleButterDesigns

These pretties will be available tomorrow at our in-person store.
Our area is calling for less than 3 inches of snow, som come see us! We’ll be open from 9-3 tomorrow!

Find us on Apple & Google Maps

#smallBusinessSaturday #shopSmallShopLocal #weCanShip #shopUsONLINE #AppleButterDesigns

So blessed with support for our small business!

Open today (November 28) and tomorrow Small Business Saturday from 9-3. Come stop in and shop while sipping on warm & cozy spiced apple cider .

Place your personalized ornament orders at appleButterDesigns.com

So blessed with support for our small business!

Open today (November 28) and tomorrow Small Business Saturday from 9-3. Come stop in and shop while sipping on warm & cozy spiced apple cider .

Place your personalized ornament orders at appleButterDesigns.com

We can’t wait to see everyone today!! We’ll be open from 9-3 today, November 28.

-Melissa

#blackFriday2025 #smallBusinessOpenHouse #shopSmallThisChristmas #personalizedOrnaments #uniqueGifts #appleButterDesigns

We can’t wait to see everyone today!! We’ll be open from 9-3 today, November 28.

-Melissa

#blackFriday2025 #smallBusinessOpenHouse #shopSmallThisChristmas #personalizedOrnaments #uniqueGifts #appleButterDesigns

We again want to say THANK YOU!! So as a special THANK YOU please enjoy $5 off your next ONLINE* order of $45+
use promo code THANKS5 at checkout

Shop us at appleButterDesigns.com

*Please note this promo code is good for our only our online store*

We appreciate and are so grateful for each and every one of you!

We again want to say THANK YOU!! So as a special THANK YOU please enjoy $5 off your next ONLINE* order of $45+
use promo code THANKS5 at checkout

Shop us at appleButterDesigns.com

*Please note this promo code is good for our only our online store*

We appreciate and are so grateful for each and every one of you!

Happy THANKSGIVING! We’re thankful for YOU, our customers, friends, and family!

We hope everyone enjoys today with full hearts and full bellies!

We’ll see you all tomorrow Black Friday and Small Business Saturday from 9-3!

#Thanksgiving2025 #ｔｈａｎｋｓｇｉｖｉｎｇ２０２５ #TurkeyDay #ShelbyCounty #ShelbyvilleINDIANA #LocalBlackFridayShopping #SmallBusinessSaturday #personalizedOrnaments #UniqueChristmasGifts #appleButterDesigns #weTurnYourMemoriesInToKeepsakes

Happy THANKSGIVING! We’re thankful for YOU, our customers, friends, and family!

We hope everyone enjoys today with full hearts and full bellies!

We’ll see you all tomorrow Black Friday and Small Business Saturday from 9-3!

#Thanksgiving2025 #ｔｈａｎｋｓｇｉｖｉｎｇ２０２５ #TurkeyDay #ShelbyCounty #ShelbyvilleINDIANA #LocalBlackFridayShopping #SmallBusinessSaturday #personalizedOrnaments #UniqueChristmasGifts #appleButterDesigns #weTurnYourMemoriesInToKeepsakes

I promise .. this will be our last new ornament release of the 2025 season.

After a customer reached out to me last night requesting a special keepsake with her loved one’s handwriting (not pictured… this is my own kiddo’s 🥰) I knew I needed to create something amazing and share this one with all of you.

This is a large 4.5” single layer ornament with see-through accents.

All I need from you is a clear photo of your loved one’s handwriting. Not the physical piece. How cool is that?!?

Order yours in our online store or stop by on Black Friday (November 28) and/or Small business Saturday (November 29) between 9-3 ..

AppleButterDesigns.com

#ChristmasKeepsake #PersonalizedOrnaments #lovedOnesHamdwriting #laserEngraving #appleButterDesigns

I promise .. this will be our last new ornament release of the 2025 season.

After a customer reached out to me last night requesting a special keepsake with her loved one’s handwriting (not pictured… this is my own kiddo’s 🥰) I knew I needed to create something amazing and share this one with all of you.

This is a large 4.5” single layer ornament with see-through accents.

All I need from you is a clear photo of your loved one’s handwriting. Not the physical piece. How cool is that?!?

Order yours in our online store or stop by on Black Friday (November 28) and/or Small business Saturday (November 29) between 9-3 ..

AppleButterDesigns.com

#ChristmasKeepsake #PersonalizedOrnaments #lovedOnesHamdwriting #laserEngraving #appleButterDesigns

Did you know that sometimes… sometimes .. that our orders are so customized that occasionally we get drawings and doodles from our customers? Yep!! And I think it’s totally AWESOME!!

Did you know that sometimes… sometimes .. that our orders are so customized that occasionally we get drawings and doodles from our customers? Yep!! And I think it’s totally AWESOME!!

The day sped past me faster than I thought… Tomorrow a few of these handpainted pretty ornaments will be added to the online store

The day sped past me faster than I thought… Tomorrow a few of these handpainted pretty ornaments will be added to the online store

Sunday Spotlight: Your Loved One’s Own Handwriting….. we can create a one-of-a-kind keepsake from your precious memories. Whether it’s their signature on a birthday card, a scribble on a receipt, even notes they’ve written in their Bible, we pay careful attention to every detail to create your unique sign that is sure to bring happy tears to the recipient.

Order yours today
https://www.applebutterdesigns.com/product-page/loved-one-s-own-handwriting-keepsake

#keepsake #creatingKeepsakesFromMemories #turningMemoriesIntoKeepsakes #appleButterDesigns #Indiana #handwritten #oneOfAkindGift #christmasGiftIdea #specializingInMemories

Sunday Spotlight: Your Loved One’s Own Handwriting….. we can create a one-of-a-kind keepsake from your precious memories. Whether it’s their signature on a birthday card, a scribble on a receipt, even notes they’ve written in their Bible, we pay careful attention to every detail to create your unique sign that is sure to bring happy tears to the recipient.

Order yours today
https://www.applebutterdesigns.com/product-page/loved-one-s-own-handwriting-keepsake

#keepsake #creatingKeepsakesFromMemories #turningMemoriesIntoKeepsakes #appleButterDesigns #Indiana #handwritten #oneOfAkindGift #christmasGiftIdea #specializingInMemories

Should I had him to our online store? Cause ai think he’s sooo cute!!!

Thank you @dani_lee000 for the inspiration!

Should I had him to our online store? Cause ai think he’s sooo cute!!!

Thank you @dani_lee000 for the inspiration!

Make every meal special with our handcrafted Festive Napkin Holders! Perfect for any napkin style and customizable to match your decor. Can't wait to see how y'all paint yours! Tag us in the pics!

Get yours now! Link in Bio

#HomeDecor #Dining #FestiveSeason #tableSeason #ChristmasTablewear #HolidayTables #DIYnapkinHolders #paintItYourself #appleButterDesigns

Make every meal special with our handcrafted Festive Napkin Holders! Perfect for any napkin style and customizable to match your decor. Can't wait to see how y'all paint yours! Tag us in the pics!

Get yours now! Link in Bio

#HomeDecor #Dining #FestiveSeason #tableSeason #ChristmasTablewear #HolidayTables #DIYnapkinHolders #paintItYourself #appleButterDesigns

.pro-gallery-wix-wrapper {display: block !important;} .pro-gallery-wix-wrapper .gallery-item-container {opacity: 1 !important; display: block !important;}

Follow us on Instagram

@applebutter_designs

Apple Butter Designs, LLC

Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

Melissa@applebutterdesigns.com

Located in the mini-barn at 4432 E 750 N

Shelbyville, Indiana 46176 317-395-3112

©2025 by Apple Butter Designs. All rights reserved.

bottom of page